Attended the "Town Hall" meeting of Patrick McHenry, the representative of North Carolina's 10th district. I left after about an hour and a half and there were still large numbers of people standing in the aisle to ask him questions or make comments. It was a demonstrative audience of perhaps 1,000 people and the meeting was very civil with no arguments or shouting being apparent. And of course, it was a meeting for a republican representative.
My observations: There is the presence of power here. It is evident in numerous small groups of men standing together, looking very knowledgeable. But the feeling went much farther than that, I felt an echo from my childhood back in a different place and a very different time. But there was the feeling of hidden power. McHenry made a number of disparaging remarks about the current administration but was not directly disrespectful to the president. It was apparent from the applause that President Obama is extremely unpopular with the group here present and so is the Democratic Party. Most of the derogatory remarks toward Obama were made by a few of the questioners. One man who identified himself as an MD here in Hickory, stated in absolutely positive terms that Obama's health care plan would place him in the role of advising older patients to terminate their life and he didn't like that. (I would have thought him to be a "plant" except for his claiming to be a local MD - someone in the audience mentioned though that he was an outspoken critic of Obama). A woman said that the 48 million people with no health care was due to illegal immigrants (Loud applause). McHenry himself indicated that many of those 48 million people were under the age of 25 and thought they would live forever. Another woman said that because of Obama's plan, our tax dollars would be used to pay for abortions - she didn't think that was right. (Very loud applause). McHenry made some awkward comment about there being several versions of the plan, and the abortion thing being smuggled into it while he and other men were in the rest room. (Or something like that - several times I found myself wondering if McHenry was intentionally playing the role of bumbling confused person simply to dodge an issue and change the topic - I suspect that is one of his characteristics.)
McHenry said he wants to provide tax credits so we can buy insurance, and he wants no discrimination for pre-conditions. Again my observations indicated that most of the people who were questioning or commenting seemed to be looking for help, many of them seemed open to government sponsored health care. There was a small group of people who applauded that idea on three or four occasions. Whenever McHenry seemed confused he would run to his platitudes and make a comment about Obama, or end of life screenings, or abortion and the applause would bring a satisfied-looking smile to his face. One woman asked McHenry why the administrative costs of the average insurance company was 30% of their total costs while Medicare and Medicaid were only 3%. I could not hear his answer to this because of a baby screaming in the audience.
Signs of plants? 1) Certainly when McHenry came in, a small tight group of men in the front rows stage right rose with shouts and clapping. Most of the crowd then rose too. 2) Clearly the doctor seemed to be a plant, although one wonders if an MD would compromise his position in the community. 3) When Tort Reform was mentioned, that same group of men stage right in the first several rows whopped, rose and cheered - and of course, so did the rest of the audience. 4) Again when one woman blamed the illegal immigrants for the medical problem, and 5) When a couple of women said we would all have to pay for abortions. In summary, if these were plants they fell far short of the "Hallway Hooligans" of the Florida Recount, and would have been pathetic in comparison with other contemporaneous ones we have seen on TV, and they were basically washed away by the personal stories some of the people told.
No comments:
Post a Comment